Empire Season 1: Richard and His Girlfriend Needed to GO — Is THAT Why We Never Got Season 2?
Okay, I have a question.
And I need somebody to answer it without getting mad.
Was Richard and his girlfriend part of the reason Empire couldn't make it to Season 2?
Because BABY...
I was watching Season 1 and thinking, “How long are we going to keep doing this?”
Now before somebody comes running into the comments ready to fight me, understand something: I'm talking about the CHARACTERS and the storyline. I'm not coming for the actors personally.
But Richard and that girlfriend?
They needed to pack a duffel bag, call an Uber, and exit stage left.
Immediately.
Richard, Baby... What Are We Doing?
Every show needs drama.
Every show needs somebody who's going to irritate us.
Every show needs that character who walks into the room and makes you say:
“Oh Lord, here HE come.”
That's television.
But there's a difference between a character creating entertaining drama and a character making me wonder why we're still spending screen time on them.
Richard started giving me the second one.
Every time we went back into that situation, I was sitting there like:
“Didn't we already discuss this?”
I needed movement.
I needed escalation.
I needed something that made me care.
Instead, sometimes it felt like Richard's storyline was driving around Chicago looking for parking.
Round and round.
And round.
And ROUND.
Sir, PARK THE CAR.
And Then Here Comes the Girlfriend
Chile.
Richard's girlfriend wasn't helping matters either.
Because when BOTH people in a storyline start getting on your nerves, we have a problem.
Usually one person is supposed to save the situation.
If Richard is doing too much, maybe the girlfriend gives us something interesting.
If the girlfriend is doing too much, maybe Richard pulls the storyline together.
But when I'm watching BOTH of y'all thinking:
“Can we get back to everybody else?”
That's dangerous.
Because television viewers are shady.
We don't have patience anymore.
People have streaming services, YouTube, TikTok, Instagram, podcasts, reality television and about 47 shows sitting in their watchlist.
You have to KEEP US.
And whenever a storyline makes somebody reach for their phone?
Uh-oh.
That's when the relationship between the audience and the show starts getting shaky.
Were They Really the Reason There Was No Season 2?
Now let's be fair.
I cannot sit here and declare that Richard and his girlfriend were THE reason Empire didn't receive another season without actual evidence from the network or producers saying that.
That would be gossip dressed up like journalism.
And although I LOVE some gossip...
We still need facts.
Television shows can end for all kinds of reasons: ratings, budgets, contracts, scheduling, network strategy, production costs or simply executives deciding they want to move in another direction.
So I'm not saying:
“Richard canceled the show!”
LOL.
Imagine having that much power.
Richard walks into a scene and somewhere an executive screams:
“CANCEL SEASON TWO!”
No.
But I AM asking whether storylines like Richard's could have contributed to viewers losing interest.
That's a completely different conversation.
Because if enough viewers aren't invested in enough of the characters, you've got a problem.
Season 1 Needed Some Trimming
Sometimes the problem isn't that a show is terrible.
The problem is that nobody knows what to CUT.
That's where I think Empire could have benefited.
You don't have to fire everybody.
You don't have to blow up the entire cast.
You just have to know when a storyline has served its purpose.
Richard and his girlfriend could have had their moment.
Give us the drama.
Give us the relationship mess.
Give us the arguments.
Give us the confusion.
Then wrap it UP.
Put a bow on it.
Send them to Atlanta.
Have somebody get a job in Houston.
Tell us they moved to Charlotte.
I don't care!
Just move the story FORWARD.
Because once the audience starts feeling like they're watching the same emotional conversation over and over, the drama stops being drama.
It becomes homework.
And I did not turn on my television to complete an assignment.
Where Was the JUICE?
That's what I kept wanting.
JUICE.
Give me somebody with a secret.
Give me somebody cheating.
Give me somebody lying.
Give me somebody stealing.
Give me somebody's mama showing up unannounced.
Give me a cousin who everybody thought was in prison walking through the front door at Thanksgiving.
SOMETHING!
This is Empire.
I want mess.
I want ambition.
I want people fighting over power.
I want somebody walking into a room wearing an outfit they cannot afford while owing everybody money.
That's ENTERTAINMENT.
Richard and his girlfriend sometimes felt like they were in a completely different show.
Everybody else could be serving prime-time drama and then suddenly here comes this relationship situation again.
Me:
“Oh...we're back over here?”
The Girlfriend Needed More
And here's another thing.
If you're going to keep Richard's girlfriend around, then DEVELOP HER.
Don't just make her somebody's girlfriend.
Give her a storyline.
Give her motives.
Give her secrets.
Give her something SHE wants.
Maybe she's using Richard.
Maybe Richard is using her.
Maybe she secretly wants something connected to the Empire.
Maybe she's playing everybody.
Maybe she's smarter than everybody realizes.
THAT would have gotten my attention.
I want to look at a character in Episode 2 and think one thing, then get to Episode 8 and realize:
“WAIT A DAMN MINUTE. SHE WAS PLAYING EVERYBODY?!”
Now we're cooking.
That's the kind of mess that makes people binge.
But if somebody is simply standing beside a man while I'm already tired of HIS storyline?
Baby, we're sinking together.
Richard Could Have Been Better Too
And I'm not even saying Richard had to disappear completely.
Maybe the character just needed a stronger direction.
Give Richard a transformation.
Make us hate him.
Then make us understand him.
Then make us hate him AGAIN.
That's good television.
I don't need every character to be likable.
Actually, sometimes the characters I can't stand are my favorites because they make the show interesting.
But give me a REASON to keep watching them.
Make Richard dangerous.
Make him funny.
Make him manipulative.
Make him ambitious.
Make him secretly broke.
Make him secretly rich.
Make him somebody's secret cousin.
I DON'T KNOW.
Do something!
Because television characters need layers.
Maybe Season 2 Could Have Fixed Everything
That's actually the frustrating part.
A second season could have given the writers an opportunity to clean things up.
Season 1 establishes the world.
Season 2 is when you start figuring out what works.
Keep the characters audiences respond to.
Reduce the storylines people don't care about.
Introduce new blood.
Raise the stakes.
And PLEASE bring in somebody who enters the room already causing trouble.
Season 2 Richard?
Maybe I would have loved him.
Season 2 girlfriend?
Maybe she would have become the villain we didn't know we needed.
That's why cancellations can be frustrating.
Sometimes you can see the potential even when the first season isn't perfect.
But Let's Talk About Chemistry
This is another major issue television producers sometimes underestimate.
CHEMISTRY.
You can hire talented actors.
You can write beautiful dialogue.
You can spend money on wardrobe.
You can build gorgeous sets.
But if the audience doesn't feel chemistry between the characters, something is missing.
And chemistry doesn't only mean romantic chemistry.
Friendships need chemistry.
Enemies need chemistry.
Families need chemistry.
Two people who absolutely HATE each other can have incredible chemistry.
Sometimes better than the couples!
I needed Richard's relationship to make me emotionally invested.
I needed to either want them together or desperately want them apart.
Instead, there were moments where my biggest emotional reaction was:
“Can we go to the next scene?”
OUCH.
Somebody in That Writers' Room Needed to Be Shady
Because if I had been sitting in that writers' room...
Honey.
I would have raised my hand.
“Excuse me. Can we talk about Richard?”
Everybody would have gotten quiet.
I'd say:
“Okay. What exactly are we doing with him?”
Because sometimes you need that one shady person in the writers' room willing to say what everybody else is thinking.
THIS AIN'T WORKING.
Not the actor.
Not necessarily the character.
The STORY.
Fix it.
Television doesn't have unlimited time.
Every minute you give one storyline is a minute you're taking away from somebody else.
So every storyline has to earn its place.
Could Richard and His Girlfriend Have Been Written Out?
I would've done it.
SORRY.
Not necessarily forever.
I would've sent them away toward the end of Season 1.
Then, if Season 2 happened, Richard could unexpectedly return around Episode 5.
But here's the catch:
He comes back DIFFERENT.
New attitude.
New money.
New clothes.
New girlfriend.
WAIT!
Now his old girlfriend sees him with the new girlfriend.
She comes back too.
Now we have a triangle.
Then we find out the new girlfriend knows the old girlfriend.
OH!
See?!
MESS.
Now I'm watching.
Now I'm making popcorn.
Now I'm canceling plans.
Now I'm yelling at the TV.
That's how you bring somebody back.
Don't bring Richard back doing the exact same thing.
Give that man a PURPOSE.
Don't Blame Everything on One Storyline
Still, we can't put an entire show's fate on Richard and his girlfriend.
That's too easy.
A television series is a machine.
Writing matters.
Casting matters.
Ratings matter.
Marketing matters.
Budget matters.
Network support matters.
Scheduling matters.
Audience buzz matters.
Streaming performance can matter.
There are many moving pieces behind whether another season happens.
So I'm not blaming Richard.
I'm just looking at him suspiciously.
LOL.
Richard, I'm watching you.
Final Thoughts
I wanted MORE from Empire Season 1.
And Richard and his girlfriend were two characters I would've seriously reconsidered if the show had continued.
Either write them out...
OR TURN THE MESS ALL THE WAY UP.
No middle ground.
I don't want lukewarm drama.
If we're going to argue, ARGUE.
If we're going to cheat, let somebody find the hotel receipt.
If we're going to lie, make it a BIG lie.
If we're going to break up, somebody better throw clothes out the window.
And if we're getting back together?
Somebody's mama better object.
That's television!
Would changing Richard's storyline have guaranteed a Season 2?
Of course not.
But could tighter storytelling and stronger character development have made the show more addictive?
That's the conversation worth having.
Now I need to hear from YOU.
Did you like Richard and his girlfriend in Season 1, or were you ready for both of them to GO?
Would you have written Richard out completely, given him a new girlfriend, or turned him into a full-blown villain for Season 2?
And most importantly:
What do YOU think kept Empire from getting another season?
Drop your opinion in the comments because I already know somebody is about to defend Richard like that's their cousin.
😂
SHARE this post with another Empire viewer and tell them to come argue with us in the comments.
Because around here, we don't just watch television.
We investigate the MESS.