When Deb’s House dropped the bomb that “R&B is dead because record companies want everyone to sound like pop stars,” I had to clutch my pearls. 💀 Now, this ain’t exactly breaking news — we’ve seen the industry push artists into chasing that shiny Top 40 sound for years. But hearing it framed so bluntly hits different.
And then, sis Karyn White (yes, the “Superwoman” legend herself) added her testimony. She admitted that when she dipped into pop, it worked for a minute… but it cost her. She didn’t even need to spell it out — we could hear the pain between the lines. The price? Losing her core Black fan base. She had to win them back, one note, one song, one performance at a time. Whew! That’s not just music, that’s ministry. 🙌🏾
When Music Ain’t Just Music
I know, I know — you’re thinking, “Isn’t music just music?” But here’s the gag: not all sounds are treated equally. When R&B artists are nudged into bubblegum pop, the soul that made them them gets watered down. And fans notice. You can’t pour heartache, church roots, and real-life struggles into a glittery, generic hook and expect it to hit the same.
Pop sells quick. R&B builds loyalty.
Record labels know this — but in the chase for Billboard charts, they often bet on what’s fast instead of what’s forever. And sadly, many artists lose themselves in the process.
Lessons from Karyn White’s Confession
Karyn’s honesty is a reminder:
- Chasing trends can give you a moment. But if you sacrifice your core audience, the moment fades fast.
- Black fans are loyal, but they don’t like feeling abandoned. If you leave them for mainstream approval, they’ll side-eye you until you prove you’re back for real.
- It’s harder to rebuild trust than it is to never lose it in the first place.
Advice: What Should Artists Do?
If you’re an artist trying to figure out your sound in a messy industry, here’s the tea:
- Stay Rooted in Your Core. Experiment, yes, but don’t forget what made your fans fall in love with you in the first place.
- Blend, Don’t Abandon. You can sprinkle in pop, house, or trap elements — but keep the R&B essence alive. Think Beyoncé: she can do country, house, and even rock, but she always brings that soul.
- Talk to Your Fans. Don’t just release what labels want. Connect with your audience. Ask them what they need, then give it to them — with your flavor.
- Play the Long Game. Pop trends are fast food. R&B is a Sunday dinner. Which one do you want your career to be remembered for?
Final Word
So, is R&B really dead? No. It’s alive, it’s breathing, it’s just waiting for artists brave enough to say “no” to the label machine and “yes” to authenticity.
Karyn White proved you can come back home. And if Deb’s House is right, then maybe we don’t need to bury R&B — we just need to resurrect it in the hearts of artists who aren’t afraid to keep it real.
Because let’s be honest: no matter how much pop sugar you sprinkle on top, soul will always taste better. 🎶✨
No comments:
Post a Comment